Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Scorpius Books's avatar

Another great article, Jamie. It's interesting you hit on the issue of no feedback for declined submissions and maybe discussing this in another post. It was the one thing I found most writers hated about trad publishing was the vague 'thanks but no thanks' responses they got from publishers when submitting. Our rejected submissions are sent a reasonably long email explaining the process and why their submission may have not made it this time around. I find it helps to at least acknowledge the writer's time and effort, even if it wasn't something I was willing to take on. I don't provide feedback as a whole, although I have made exceptions when something is very close, but just not quite there.

I also wondered about your services and how that works - I've been an editor for over 15 years prior to starting Scorpius Books and do design/editing work for companies and other publishers, but strayed from offering it to authors, feeling it may have been seen as a conflict of interest. Is this not your findings? If you edit someone's book and then don't accept it for publication, would they not question why?

Expand full comment
Nanyamka jenkins's avatar

I like this article because it answered some questions I had that I didn't even know I had. So unlike the other people who have commented I don't exactly come from a editing background so I don't want charged for this service.I don't want to look like a vanity press and like another guy said some people just assume that if you're a small press your a vanity press. I however come from a promotion background and was considering offering easy promotional service such as finding reviewers or setting up tours or website building for authors. However, I'm not sure how authors would view that if they would think we were trying to be a vanity press after all. I'm still on the fence but like you said small publishers need extra income streams.

Expand full comment
3 more comments...

No posts